One Naval Park Cove, Buffalo, NY 14202

716-997-2245

716-997-2245

  • Home
  • Murder Mystery Dinners
  • Buffalo Ghost Tours
  • Buffalo Music Bingo
  • Winery Tour
  • Evil Buffalo
  • Buffalo Horse Drawn Tours
  • More
    • Home
    • Murder Mystery Dinners
    • Buffalo Ghost Tours
    • Buffalo Music Bingo
    • Winery Tour
    • Evil Buffalo
    • Buffalo Horse Drawn Tours
  • Home
  • Murder Mystery Dinners
  • Buffalo Ghost Tours
  • Buffalo Music Bingo
  • Winery Tour
  • Evil Buffalo
  • Buffalo Horse Drawn Tours

Buffalo History Tours

Buffalo History ToursBuffalo History Tours

who murdered Supt. Andrews?

Body Found in the Diagnosis Clinic

Man lies wounded on the floor in an old diagnosis clinic.

A key is needed to enter the Clinic


Clues Found At The Murder Scene

An old wooden crutch on vintage paper.

Crutch with bloodstains.  Used to incapacitate the victim.

Vintage syringe labeled Coke-A-Cillan on aged paper.

A syringe with remnants of Coke-A-Cillan.

A red fish on a vintage paper background.

A red fish.

Embroidered white handkerchief with lace edges.

Woman's handkerchief with "JA" initials.

An eye chart with red stains on it.

Dr. Stiffington's Vitality Drops.

A pair of men's black gloves.

Supt. Andrews report outlining potential misconduct at the Asylum.


Suspects

Kate Hamlin: Pan-Am Security Official, she will act as a detective.

Dr. Sigmund Fraud:  This Austrian born Psychoanalyst sure has some interesting ideas about your relationship with your parents. Ask him about what Supt. Andrews knew about his testing of Coke-A-Cillan at the Asylum. 

Jennifer Andrews:  The grieving widow, or is she? Some whisper that she is an ambitious gold digger who saw her husband as a ticket to a higher place in society.

Ask her how she first met her late husband and what first attracted her to him.

Henry Hobson Richardson:   It appears this architect has been drawing up plans for both new buildings and the Superintendent's wife. Ask him what Dr. Andrews knew about the theft of Asylum building materials and the construction of a new mansion. 

Doctor Professor Melonfeeler:  Is the professor a real doctor? 

Ask him about his latest study and how he believes it will make him the head of the psychology profession.

Also ask about his unusual allergy. 


Preliminary Information

Hours before he was scheduled to release a report detailing alleged improprieties at the Buffalo Asylum, Superintendent Andrews was found dead inside the Diagnosis Clinic. A syringe containing traces of the drug “Coke-A-Cillan” was discovered beside the body. Preliminary findings indicate that Andrews died after being injected with a lethal dose of the substance. Investigators believe the superintendent was first rendered unconscious by a blow from a crutch, facilitating the injection.


Interrogation Tips

Ask where the suspect was during the time of the murder, i.e., do they have an alibi. Find out if they have medical expertise in using a syringe and if they have access to the Diagnosis Clinic. Ask who THEY think killed Superintendent Andrews and why. Ask suspects what they know about the clues found at the murder scene.


Copyright © 2026 Buffalo History Tours - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

  • Murder Mystery Dinners
  • Buffalo Ghost Tours
  • Buffalo Music Bingo
  • Winery Tour
  • Richardson Clue Sheet

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

DeclineAccept